Thursday, October 6, 2011

Draft Essay #3


Death by Abandonment


“Frankenstein” was a book of turmoil. I found the book to be very depressing in every way possible. Although, the story was very well put together with a great deal of element. The point to detail was allowing the reader to be placed in the settings and hearing, smelling, and seeing what was really going on. Throughout the whole reading of this story you were able to sit side by side with every character and their feelings. The story itself was good, just disheartening. The theme of “Frankenstein” was simply put to me, abandonment. Abandonment, weather self-abandonment or abandonment by death flowed throughout the book. Everywhere that Victor turned he had seen ones that he loved and that he had hated leave him, and continue to further leave him lonely in this world. Excellence and companionship was always being strived for in the book as well. When Victor went off to school, he went to become a more educated human, when he began his creation of the fiend he attempted recognition, marrying his cousin for the happiness of his mother and fathers wishes, and Walton yearning for a friend while on his voyage; just to name a few. I believe that Shelley was trying to get us to understand that everyone in this world, weather they be good or evil, strives for a sense of placement in humanity. We all want to become something great and be loved, and this book shares the hardships of trying to accomplish this for the young man Victor. Ultimately causing him so many let downs that it kills him, yet his soul had been dead long before the actual mortality of his demise. “he forfeits every comfort of life, and finally even life itself.” (Anonymous 196)
The depth of despair lurks everywhere in this amazingly creative masterpiece. As stated “We rest; a dream has power to poison sleep. We rise; one wand’ ring thought pollutes the day. We feel, conceive, or reason; laugh or weep, Embrace fond woe, or cast our cares away; It is the same: for, be it joy or sorrow, The path of its departure still is free. Man’s yesterday may ne’er be like his morrow; Naught may endure but mutability!” (Frankenstein, 64). Frankenstein’s nature is but sweet and honorable. He is predestined for a miserable life. He looks for a positive outlook yet always is pushed down. Frankenstein tries to obey every wish and accomplish every goal he has, all with a positive and open mind. Yet, every door he opens is slammed in his face with some type of mayhem that is to bring him down and give him the feeling of despair.
The personality of Frankenstein is continually emphasized throughout the reading. His quietness and compassion is shown when he is explaining his story to the new friend he made on the ship of which he was rescued. Everyday, growing weaker and more depressed thinking of his failure in not being able to reach his fiend to demolish his being. He stands up for his new friend when his crewmen question and demand him to go back as soon as the ice clears. As badly as he wishes to ask Walton to go after his fiend to complete his mission, he does not, in fear he too will bear the horrible outcome of life as he has. “This novel rests its claim on being a source of powerful and profound emotion.” (Shelley, 185) And even just for a brief moment shows compassion for the fiend he created he. When asked to make a companion of the opposite sex for the fiend he seriously contemplates this demand. Yet when truly having time to comprehend the possible outcome of this new creature, he refuses. He looks for the good in life but just cannot grasp it. Events that he tries to look forward to, he cant, in the fear of the bitter outcome that his fiend has promised him.
The fiend also shows great passion in this novel. He desires the companionship of a human, however with one look at his hideous features he is sworn a daemon. The compassion he shows to his friends in the cottage, by helping them gather wood and accomplishing chores for them at night when they cannot see him. Desperately asking for acceptance from the old blind man, and in turn getting beaten by the young son when he returns to find this creature with his incapable father. “…affectionate and full of moral sensibility, yet the circumstances of his existence are so monstrous and uncommon, that, when the consequences of them became developed in action, his original goodness was gradually turned to inextinguishable misanthropy and revenge.”  (Shelley 186) He so badly wanted to have a friend in the world and to be accepted. The ignorance of mankind made the creation become a monster, we must think if he could be accepted would be have turned out to be such a monstrosity or could he have kept his innocence and submissive demeanor? “-his natural tendency to kind feelings, and the manner in which they were blighted, -”. (Anonymous 191) It was if only he was treated with the kindness and compassion that he could have stayed a gentle creation and been one of the greatest inventions of all time.
“Frankenstein” is without a doubt one of the most creative novels ever written, bringing life, death and the troubling need for placement in the world. One who is banned to a solitary life style can only last in existence for so long without going insane. The acceptance from our peers is something we all strive for weather we choose to admit that or not. Shelley has, in all of her characters made a demanding need for that. And as hard as Frankenstein tries to achieve this he is always lacking the ability, and in the saddest manner it is in his own doings of why this cannot happen for himself. If Frankenstein would not have wanted so badly deify the rules of nature and continue to exceed himself in science he could have lived a long and prosperous life, with his family and the marriage of his cousin. And on the other hand if the fiend had been made successfully into the creation that Frankenstein had planned there was a chance for so much scientific accomplishment and wonder. And furthermore the fiend would not have been seen as an abomination and could have received the companionship and care that he had always wished to have with the human race, of which he was created out of. The Abandonment that Frankenstein felt was bitterly transferred to the fiend when he so eagerly abandoned the creation that he had made. The wretched sight of the creation was enough for Frankenstein to leave; he could have made the fiend such an astonishing accomplishment that was well educated and coherent showing his great knowledge surpassing that of his professors. Frankenstein had left his soft demeanor when he forsaken this hideous creation.  But nonetheless he abandoned this creation and therefore abandoning all hope for his happy and fruitful life he could have lived. Frankenstein had all of the makings in becoming something great with many accomplishments and the fiend completely took all of the hope of this away just because of the ways his creator and the other humans treated him. If shown Frankenstein’s true loving nature the fiend and he could have had an amazing partnership and continued their lives in an accomplished way.


Works Cited
Anonymous as cited in Frankenstein, Mary Shelley. From Edinburgh Magazine. A Norton Critical Ed. New York, London: WW Norton & Company, 191. Print.
Anonymous as cited in Frankenstein, Mary Shelley. From Gentleman's Magazine. A Norton Critical Ed. New York, London: WW Norton & Company, 196. Print.
Shelley, Mary. Frankenstein. A Norton Critical Ed. New York, London: WW Norton & Company, 64. Print.
Shelley Bysshe, Percyas as cited in, Mary Shelley. On Frankenstein. A Norton Critical Ed. New York, London: WW Norton & Company, 185 & 186. Print.

12 comments:

  1. I believe that this is a wonderful first draft for your essay. I feel that the topic you chose, Death by Abandonment, was a great topic to choose since there is such a wealth of information to find throughout the book and in the articles in the back. I feel that the quotes you had chosen were integrated into your essay quite well and it did not interrupt the flow either. I had noticed the abandonment that Victor did with the fiend but there where others that you pointed out that I had not noticed at first but then when I thought back to the story, those were there as well. Sometimes the reader (me) tend to concentrate on the main characters on not on the other things happening but I think abandonment definitely happens with Walton and Victor. I did not see any spelling errors or grammar errors and I don’t feel that there’s anything that needs to be fixed. Great job!!!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I thought that this was a great first draft. If I might make a few suggestions? Re-read your essay, I found a few wording errors throughout the paper. Also make sure you introduce your sources. I thought that your last paragraph was incredible and well worded, I really enjoyed it over all GOOD JOB!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hello Lindsey,
    This is a good draft. You cover many good points and are on the right track to a perfect essay. I might make a comment regarding the position of the quote by Percy Shelly. It is:
    “This novel rests its claim on being a source of powerful and profound emotion.” (Shelley, 185)
    One way that I might work that quote in would be a the beginning of the paragraph, right after that sentence on the emotions of Victor. Maybe you could introduce the quote as being from the authors husband to provide even more credibility for the quote. This is a good essay and I encourage you to keep up the amazing work.
    Pax et bonum,
    Joseph

    ReplyDelete
  4. I feel that this essay is very well written and that it has a lot of potential to become even greater. I agree with you that Shelley was trying to make a point about wanting to find a place to belong. I also think that the way you went about writing this essay was strong, but I think, possibly, adding more quotes from the articles in the back of the book would help back up your claims.

    ReplyDelete
  5. You have done a very good job here. I would recommend (and I know I need to do it too) that you look a little closer at how your sentences are worded and structured. Sometimes in trying to get our thoughts down in print, we make things a little too complicated to follow. Or it could just be late and my brain stopped working... just a thought!

    ReplyDelete
  6. This draft has a lot of potential! I think you have good evidence to support your point you're making. I do agree that "abandonment" was one of the many main themes in this novel. The only thing is maybe check your wording in sentences. Some of them can be shortened or worded more efficiently and your paragraph structure could be broken up a bit too. Great draft!

    ReplyDelete
  7. This first draft is super good! The abandonment issue was definitely something that I caught while reading the story also. You have really nice detail to back up your quotes. You helped point somethings out that were in the story that I didn't even catch. Nice job.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I thought this was a very good rough draft essay. You chose a great topic, which you did very well on stating your work cited info. I had also thought about this topic. I also agree with the others about some sentence structuring and your last paragraph had a lot of great material.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Great first draft! I agree that one of the themes in the book was abandonment. Maybe just re-read and fix a few grammatical errors. Other than that I thought your draft was structured nicely, as well as full of evidence and opinions. nice work!

    ReplyDelete
  10. This essay was a very good first draft! I must say that I agree Frankenstein was a very sad book to read. There are times in your essay that you write about the sadness in the book of Frankenstein and it seems as if you are putting down the book. When you do this it makes you seem like a complainer rather than the artist of writing I know you are. I can tell by your writing style. You may want to re-read your essay again and just make those areas seem a bit more polite. Other than that you did a wonderful job!

    ReplyDelete
  11. This is a good first draft. I thought the Novel was kind of depressing too. Frankenstein was full of emotion. I noticed there are some in-text citation errors in your essay. I think you need to include some more evidence from the articles. Overall I thought you gave some excellent main points/themes.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Your draft is well written. I think that having a little bit more of an introduction of the themes in the first paragraph might give the essay a little more organization.

    ReplyDelete